My Lords, I am extremely grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this SI, to which I have tabled a regret amendment. But I am afraid I take a slightly different view from the one he has just explained.
Once again, we start with an ill-thought-out, anti-business measure by this Government. It is very interesting to note that the Minister, when he was explaining and introducing the instrument, referenced a number of government agencies that will be enforcing all sorts of fines and whatnot, but he did not really talk about its impact on business, which is regrettable. Quite frankly, this will end up being an anti-worker measure too, and it will price people out of the labour market.
No one on this side of the House opposes higher pay in principle. Of course we want people to earn more but, for that to be the case, there must be work to be had. A wage floor that is set without proper regard to hiring conditions, business confidence and the fragility of entry-level employment does not help the low paid if it helps price them out of a job altogether. That is why this SI is so troubling. From 1 April, the adult rate will rise to £12.71, while the rate for 18 to 20 year-olds will rise to £10.85 and the under-18 and apprentice rates will rise to £8.
The Government may pretend that there is no trade-off here, but everyone outside government understands that there is. If one sharply compresses the wage differentials—the Minister called them “discriminatory”—between inexperienced younger workers and older workers, one makes it less attractive to hire those with the least experience, the least confidence and the least established work history. The key word is not “discrimination”; it is “experience”. That is not only true for those aged 21 to 25 who are entering the workforce but especially true for 18 to 20 year-olds, many of whom rely on part-time, flexible and entry-level work to get that crucial first foothold in the labour market. Retailers themselves are warning that these local, flexible jobs are often the first step into work for young people, including Saturday jobs and short-hours roles around study or caring responsibilities.