My Lords, the Government have told us that growth is their number one mission. That is the promise they have repeated again and again, and, given the difficult circumstances the country faces, that is sensible. That being the case, I am afraid that the Government’s statements—both that of the Chief Secretary to the Treasury to Parliament and the speech given by the Chancellor—do not measure up to the scale of what is required.
Above all, we need a recognition that the first steps of this Government—spreading pessimism; rewarding recalcitrant unions with large pay increases without them being tied to productivity increases; increasing stifling regulation, particularly on employment and renting; and increasing taxes—are precisely what should be avoided. Instead, we need an optimistic mindset—seizing the issue, and shaking up those who are not contributing and could do more—and a determination to make real progress, not a flabby wish list with no indication of how it will be achieved in practice.
Last week, Lloyds Bank announced 1,600 job cuts after the CBI warned of a “significant fall” in business activity in the private sector, and the normally robust supermarkets announced large job losses. This is before we start to feel the effects of the Government’s most burdensome measures, which come into force in April. Businesses are fearful, and consumers are showing caution in case they lose their jobs or face price rises that affect their families.
That does not mean to say the Government’s proposals are not welcome, up to a point, if they contribute to stability and growth as we hope. The expansion of Heathrow seems to be central to the Government’s plans to “unlock further growth”, but this will take well over a decade to come to fruition and seems to be highly contentious in the Cabinet. Will the present proposal outlive the Chancellor? It seems doubtful.